Start with your lens, not the holder
The NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder line is built around specific ultra-wide lenses, so the first question is not which holder is better but which one fits your lens. The two holders here are dedicated designs: one for the Canon TS-E 17mm f/4L and one for the Samyang 14mm Ultra Wide-Angle f/2.8 IF ED UMC. Both accept 150mm square filters at 2mm thickness, both rotate 360 degrees, and both can hold two filters at once. The practical differences come down to lens fit, vignetting, and availability.
Canon TS-E 17mm f/4L: dedicated fit with no black corners
- NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder For Canon TS-E 17mm F/4L: Specially designed for the Canon TS-E 17mm f/4L; holds 2 150mm filters at the same time; 360 degree rotating. This is the only holder in this comparison built for the Canon tilt-shift lens, and the dual-filter capacity plus rotation supports graduated filter use.

NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder For Canon TS-E 17mm F/4L - NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder For Canon TS-E 17mm F/4L: No black corners or vignetting. That is the key optical promise for a super-wide tilt-shift lens, where filter holders often intrude into the frame.
- NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder For Canon TS-E 17mm F/4L: This product has been discontinued and replaced by the S5 system. If you are buying new for the Canon lens, check S5 availability first; this Q holder may only be found as remaining stock.
Samyang 14mm f/2.8: dedicated fit with slight corner vignetting
- NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder For Samyang 2.8/14mm: Specially designed for the Samyang 14mm Ultra Wide-Angle f/2.8 IF ED UMC Lens but may also work with other wide-angle lenses. The primary fit is the Samyang 14mm f/2.8; the broader compatibility is stated only as a possibility, so confirm your lens before relying on it.

NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder For Samyang 2.8/14mm - NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder For Samyang 2.8/14mm: Holds 2 150mm filters at the same time; 360 degree rotating. Like the Canon version, it supports stacked filters and rotation, which matters for balancing sky and foreground with a graduated filter.
- NiSi 150mm Q Filter Holder For Samyang 2.8/14mm: Slight vignetting at corners. This is the honest trade-off versus the Canon holder's no-vignetting claim; on the Samyang lens you may see slight corner darkening.
What actually differs between the two holders
- Lens fit: Canon holder is for the Canon TS-E 17mm f/4L only. Samyang holder is for the Samyang 14mm f/2.8 and may work with other wide-angle lenses. Neither is a universal holder.
- Vignetting: The Canon holder is listed as having no black corners or vignetting. The Samyang holder is listed with slight vignetting at corners.
- Filter capacity: Both hold up to two 150mm filters at the same time and rotate 360 degrees.
- Availability: The Canon Q holder is discontinued and replaced by the S5 system. The Samyang Q holder is not listed as discontinued in the supplied information.
- Build: Both use aviation-grade aluminum, CNC machining, a matte black frosted finish, and copper screws with black nickel plating.
Why a tilt-shift lens changes the filter decision
A tilt-shift lens like the Canon TS-E 17mm f/4L moves the front of the lens relative to the sensor, and a filter holder must be designed around that movement. The supplied information says this holder is specially designed for that lens and produces no black corners or vignetting, but it does not describe how the holder attaches or whether it accommodates every shift and tilt position. If you regularly use large movements, confirm the mounting behavior with the retailer before you buy, especially since this model has been replaced by the S5 system.
What the supplied information does not confirm
Neither record includes installation steps, adapter-ring requirements, or a list of other lenses that are confirmed to work. The Samyang holder says it may work with other wide-angle lenses, but that is not a guarantee. Filter thickness is specified as 2mm for both. If you need a holder for a different lens, these two are not interchangeable substitutes; check the S5 system or a holder listed for your specific lens.



